Survivor's Jeff Probst Explains Why The Million-Dollar Coin Flip Was Revived For The Open Era
"Survivor 51" finally delivered what Jeff Probst promised to the castaways in the very first episode: The $1 million coin flip is back, baby!
And for one challenge-dominating player, Lewis, it's perfect timing. His luck was just about to run out. The extremely well-fed Irishman (merge feast, spaghetti, and a fried chicken picnic? I thought people were supposed to starve on this show!) had backed himself into a corner with his copious challenge wins, and the rest of the cast was starting to take notice. So after Devin warned Lewis with his "weaponized honesty," Lewis knew he was in danger. (He also said it himself: "I almost dug my own grave by being so good at these challenges.") What a perfect time to step up at Tribal Council and take destiny into his own hands. So he flipped the coin.
Unfortunately, after calling "fire" for the coin flip, Probst's shiny gold coin turned up... water. And Lewis's 50/50 shot at safety, immunity idol, and $2 million went up in smoke.
According to Probst, one of the reasons why production wanted to revive the coin flip twist so soon stemmed from Rick Devens' overjoyed reaction in Season 50. "That shocked me," the host wrote in his weekly episode Field Notes shared with press. "He found joy in a moment I thought players might dread."
Would a new group share that enthusiasm toward such a potentially deadly opportunity? That was part of the allure of bringing the twist back.
"Devens and Lewis got opposite results. But they both embodied the same exact enthusiasm," Probst said. "And I think that spirit is a big part of why both are audience favorites. They make you want to see what they'll do next. The players are always teaching us. Yes, we design the game, but the players are the ones who decide what to do with it. In this case, they helped me see 'flip the coin' as a metaphor for something bigger."
He continued: "Watching someone like Lewis give themselves permission to have the experience they came for can remind us of who we'd like to be. This is one of the many things that keeps 'Survivor' so inspiring to me — wondering who will show up next — and what will make them raise their hand. Every player has to decide which risks make sense for their game. For Devens and Lewis, it was the coin flip. They saw something they wanted to experience, and they raised their hands."
Despite Devin and Christian initially throwing their hat inside the ring for the coin flip, Lewis stepped up knowing his neck was on the line. "At least I know I'm on the chopping block, so let me embrace this chaos and go out swinging!" he said. And that he did.
What else went down in Episode 9?
* With Kristin now sitting on the jury bench, Sharonda's stock continued to rise. She explained in the episode how she not only tipped off Devin and Jelly about the vote last week, but simultaneously wrote their names down, knowing that the idol would be played. She couldn't have known that Kristin and Kilby would ultimately take the fall (Jelly and Devin split their two votes, after all), but stand proud is exactly what Sharonda did. At least in a private interview. "I'm taking all this credit for the Tribal, just not out loud right now," she said. Sounds like something the future winner of "Survivor 51" would say!
* One moment from Wednesday's episode absolutely tickled me, and that was: Devin "finding" his own fake idol. In an attempt to lead a horse to water — in this case, Maggie to the "idol" — Devin made a huge blunder when his attempt to "give" Maggie the advantage failed big time. She refused, naturally, which made the whole ordeal an absolute comedy show. Devin's storytelling capabilities were on full display as he recounted the tale via interview. But now Maggie thinks she has some prized intel. What is she going to do with said intel? It's unclear, but she's no dummy. If she can use it to her advantage, she will! But what a treat this little snippet was. If you're going to go through the effort of planting a fake, at least have the patience for your seed to bloom!
* Did anyone else clock that Kristin was rolling her eyes every time Christian spoke? Sure, he was humblebragging about getting safety from his Shot in the Dark last week, but I couldn't help but giggle at the looks Kristin was serving.
* Who else is majorly worried for Devin and Jelly? As we saw in the previews, Maggie seems to be on to the fact that Devin's "idol" is fake. And Jelly doesn't seem to be out of the woods yet either. Maggie and Thien An have it out for her. Thien An said Jelly doesn't even look at her? (Wonder what's the tea there.)
So what say you, "Survivor" fans? Did this coin flip pack as much of a punch as it did in "50"? Hit that comments section and go full tilt boogie!