Frozen's Elsa Is Coming To Once Upon A Time - But Who Should Play Her? Our Top 10 Picks

By Andy Swift May 12, 2014 5:49 pm EST

once-upon-a-time-elsa-laura-vandervoort

Laura Vandervoort Currently starring on Syfy's Bitten, it's possible the former Smallville star could squeeze a Once arc between seasons, TV gods willing.

Laura Vandervoort

Currently starring on Syfy's Bitten, it's possible the former Smallville star could squeeze a Once arc between seasons, TV gods willing.

once-upon-a-time-elsa-blake-lively

Blake Lively The former Gossip Girl star has been out of the TV game for far too long. Plus, who knows more about being an ice queen than one of "Manhattan's elite"?

Blake Lively

The former Gossip Girl star has been out of the TV game for far too long. Plus, who knows more about being an ice queen than one of "Manhattan's elite"?

once-upon-a-time-elsa-maggie-grace

Maggie Grace The Once EPs have a habit of hiring actors they worked with on Lost, and we don't think they should let that go before bringing Grace into the fold.

Maggie Grace

The Once EPs have a habit of hiring actors they worked with on Lost, and we don't think they should let that go before bringing Grace into the fold.

once-upon-a-time-elsa-elizabeth-mitchell

Elizabeth Mitchell Another Lost grad, Mitchell has a wide-open schedule now that NBC has decided to cancel Revolution after two seasons. Next stop: Storybrooke!

Elizabeth Mitchell

Another Lost grad, Mitchell has a wide-open schedule now that NBC has decided to cancel Revolution after two seasons. Next stop: Storybrooke!

once-upon-a-time-elsa-claire-holt

Claire Holt No stranger to the supernatural -- she's played a mermaid and a vampire thus far -- Holt has some free time in her schedule now that she's no longer a series regular on The CW's The Originals.

Claire Holt

No stranger to the supernatural — she's played a mermaid and a vampire thus far — Holt has some free time in her schedule now that she's no longer a series regular on The CW's The Originals.

once-upon-a-time-elsa-megan-hilty

Megan Hilty Should the residents of Storybrooke demand an impromptu performance of "Let It Go," we're pretty sure Hilty could come through in a pinch.

Megan Hilty

Should the residents of Storybrooke demand an impromptu performance of "Let It Go," we're pretty sure Hilty could come through in a pinch.

once-upon-a-time-elsa-dianna-agron

Dianna Agron A gorgeous young woman who sets out to defy society's expectations of her? Elsa sounds a lot like Glee's Quinn Fabray -- but with even more magic!

Dianna Agron

A gorgeous young woman who sets out to defy society's expectations of her? Elsa sounds a lot like Glee's Quinn Fabray — but with even more magic!

once-upon-a-time-elsa-greer-grammer

Greer Grammer Immediately following the Frozen reveal, the Awkward star tweeted, "YOU GUYS - HOW DO I GET TO BE ELSA ON ONCE UPON A TIME?!?!? THIS IS NOT A DRILL."

Greer Grammer

Immediately following the Frozen reveal, the Awkward star tweeted, "YOU GUYS – HOW DO I GET TO BE ELSA ON ONCE UPON A TIME?!?!? THIS IS NOT A DRILL."

once-upon-a-time-elsa-natalie-dormer

Natalie Dormer Her road to queendom has been rocky -- to say the least -- on Game of Thrones. Maybe Dormer would have better luck in Storybrooke.

Natalie Dormer

Her road to queendom has been rocky — to say the least — on Game of Thrones. Maybe Dormer would have better luck in Storybrooke.

once-upon-a-time-elsa-kristen-bell

Kristen Bell Once loves putting a twist on beloved stories -- and what could be more twisted than having Bell, who played Elsa's sister Anna in the movie, take on the role of the ice queen?

Kristen Bell

Once loves putting a twist on beloved stories — and what could be more twisted than having Bell, who played Elsa's sister Anna in the movie, take on the role of the ice queen?