Survivor 51's [Spoiler] Reveals Unaired Scheme He Pulled On Brady: Toka Was 'Unbelievably Chaotic'

Add TVLine on Google:
Google Discover

The following contains spoilers from Wednesday's episode of "Survivor 51"!

Lewis Kelly took fate into his own hands.

In Wednesday's "Survivor," the coin flip we've all been waiting for returned to throw a wrench in everyone's Tribal Council plans. Luckily (or unluckily?) for Lewis, he knew his name was on the chopping block, so when it came time to decide who was going to flip that million-dollar coin, he, Devin, and Christian stepped up to the plate as potential candidates. After some excited discussion, Devin and Christian stepped aside, letting Irish farmer Lewis choose his own destiny. But the coin fiasco didn't go his way, and with one flip and one wrong call, he became the 12th person to leave the game. (Read what Jeff Probst had to say about Lewis' flip here.) 

Below, Lewis talks to TVLine about what it felt like to take the spotlight at Tribal, how his challenge performance made him a huge threat, his time on Exile Island, and so much more.

TVLINE | Let's start with this coin flip. How did it feel standing up there with Jeff, coin in your hand, with all that pressure?
LEWIS KELLY | I was just grateful, honestly. I felt like it was somewhat fate. I did not anticipate making it this far in this game, to be quite honest with you. And the one day the target is all locked on Lewis, Jeff brings out the coin. I was like, this is kind of my fate.

TVLINE | Devin and Christian both wanted to flip the coin. Was there any more to those conversations at Tribal that we didn't see?
That was a long Tribal. I held them hostage there. We were there for like two-and-a-half, maybe more, hours, because I was like, this is my last Tribal, I'll take my time. There's no f***ing rush. So, it was a lot of back and forth. It was a lot of me checking in with my alliance, trying to read the room, where people were with me. Ultimately I came to the decision: People were not with me. So I flipped it.

TVLINE | Devin clued you in to the danger you were potentially in. But what else did you know about the conversations happening around you and the potential plan to vote you out?
I felt like I had a really good lay of the land. I think coming from Exile gave me that as a kind of blessing of like, I knew where the alliances laid. I knew everyone's number ones because I wasn't in them. I wasn't meshed into them. I knew I was on the chopping block. I actually pitched, I was like, bro, me and Sharonda have this alliance forming, hopefully. I was like, "Why don't we go for Maggie?," because it's either me or I can hop onto a helicopter. I pitched to Sharonda, Devin, and Jelly, let's go for Maggie. 

Here's the thing. Twenty minutes later, Thien An comes over to me and she's like, "You're pitching Maggie?" and I was like, oh, I'm screwed. And then Devin's sitting me down and pitching me that. I'm thinking in my head, "I already gave the pitch to Maggie, so what are you talking about?" He's telling me that, and I'm grateful, because I think it's a really fun, different gameplay to the rest of it. I'm like, this is fun, but I'm not gonna pitch you someone because 1) you already ratted on me for going for Maggie, and 2) I didn't necessarily feel like he had the sway to make a vote, to sway people onto another vote. I was like, I could sit here and try and pretend you're gonna get the vote off of me, [but] I didn't think Devin had that power to do it, so I didn't even try.

Lewis was surprised his challenge performances were a factor

TVLINE | Would performing worse in challenges actually have helped you this season?
I could not have anticipated in a million years being good at challenges. I did not put myself forward for that slingshot challenge. I didn't think I'd be good. I got the three targets in four shots, so I didn't even have time to process, "Oh, am I being too good at this?" I kind of blindsided myself at being good at those challenges, equally as it did other people. It was hard for me and, in hindsight, I didn't think physical threat is the caliber of play everyone was playing. I thought people were playing above that caliber, of like, OK, physical threat, "No one's gonna win all the challenges. So who else can we get out? Who's really running the show?" But people were hungry and what they don't show you is realistically, I got screwed over by two helicopters because that helicopter ride, we did a drive by four times, twisting the f***ing knife in them that they didn't get to go. I'm like, are you serious? We're driving by again? I mean, I ate really good out there for the second half of the game. People are hungry. I don't know. I didn't think that was going to be something that came into gameplay like, you're really gonna vote someone out because you're hungry?

TVLINE | They were hangry, I guess!
Very hangry, indeed, yeah.

TVLINE | If you had survived the coin flip, what would your path to the end have looked like?
I probably would have just bluffed the idol, played an idol, played my pot idol, bluffed my pot idol. I would have just come out with all the tricks up my sleeve to try and maneuver myself to the end, but I already had a target. Imagine flipping the coin and getting it, how blown out of proportion that target would have been. It would have been a wild ride for me to get to the end.

TVLINE | We saw you survive a crazy tie-vote situation, and we saw you try to fake a blood ring idol. You were gaming hard! Did you have any schemes or other major moments that did not make it to air?
I actually did a successful blood idol when I first entered Toka. I was like, they could just want the newbie out. So I went in there and I was like, who's running the show? Who's calling shots? I called it to be Brady. So I told Brady I lost the challenge, had to link my life with someone for one Tribal, and I linked it to you because I knew you were a strong physical dude. You're running the show, and he made a pact with me like, "I'll ride or die for you, we'll protect each other." Now, in hindsight, I didn't f***ing need that because people were coming for each other. It was unbelievably chaotic. You'd never find more than two people in one conversation on the early Toka beach. It was madness. So, I didn't end up needing it, but that was fun. I actually pulled something off successfully once.

How Exile Island affected Lewis' game

TVLINE | You spent the first bit of the game at Exile Island. Why did you choose to volunteer for that and did that stunt your game at all in those early days?
I can't complain because I made it unbelievably farther than I ever would have imagined, right? I saw it as a blessing and a curse. So the curse is I was never really anyone's No. 1 or No. 2. I came in more of a number. So I was more people's third and fourth to their alliances. But the blessing, I felt like it gave me a really good analytical perspective of where the lines were, who was allied. Everyone thought everyone was their friend, and everyone thought they could trust everyone with information. I was like, this person is working with this person, this is how it is. 

And now my difficulty was trying to transfer that information to the players who already had all these preconceived ideas. I tried to tell Kilby, "Jelly and Brady are not with you." He did not believe me. Thien An, I was like, Brady is gunning against you. Thien An did not believe me. I tried to even pitch to Mike. Later, during the merge, I was like, here's the lay of the land. We have Devin and Jelly, Sharonda and Eric, Carter and Christian, and Thien An and Maggie. "Me and you are stragglers. Let's work together and eliminate one person from each of these duos, right?" It's just hard because Mike clearly thought he was in a different position in the game. The difficult part is not being able to see where the cards lie, it's being able to convince people that that's where they lie.

TVLINE | We saw how torn up your hands got from that axe chopping task on Exile. How long did that take to heal up?
They were in bits for the entire f***ing game. It was actually so nasty. They were a lot worse than they showed. They were bleeding, it was like scabbed over, and they'd get ripped up every single challenge, so it was a bad way to start the game.

TVLINE | Kilby really stepped up for you at the tied-up Linnea vote. How much did losing Kilby in the duo's twist affect your game?
Ultimately in hindsight, he was a big threat who always would have went before me. But at the same time, I was starting to pick him up as a threat too, but, you know, it's just a matter of when you do it. I don't know. I honestly wish I just stood on business for Kilby, handed him my immunity necklace. That was a plan the whole time, but Sharonda and I would have had to do it together, so it made it more complicated. But yeah, when I came from Exile, I went to everyone, I gave them the same spiel. I said, "I wanna play crazy, I wanna play chaotic, I wanna play wild," and that either scared people or it attracted people, and it attracted Kilby, and that was the moment I knew. OK, we can have fun in this game. We can cause chaos. It was kind of bittersweet because I scared the other people of like, he's kinda crazy, you know?

TVLINE | What was the hardest part of this experience for you?
Oh God, the weather is so... I mean, as an Irish person, the weather is vile. It is sweltering. You can't escape it, so there's the mental, but there's the [physicality] of the weather. It's tough. That storm, I think that was the worst night of my life. That was rotten. I've always heard the phrase "cold to the bone." That's the first time I ever experienced it where it was like 12 hours of getting rain on you. It was nasty.

TVLINE | If you could run the same game back over again, is there anything you'd do differently? 
Do you know what? I wouldn't because I had so much fun. I don't really want to think of things in forms of regret because I thought I was gonna be the first or second boot. I really thought I wasn't gonna make it far. So I am honestly honored to be able to fulfill so many "Survivor" experiences, and to make it that f***ing far is crazy.

Recommended